There's more, but the bottom line is that until Hasbro acknowledges the FCP isn't worth the paper it's not printed upon, there is still an avenue of attack. Pay attention, publishers, fan creators.
And Hasbro? YOU listen up. We have a hundred thousand expert rules lawyer DMs, a million min-maxers, and dozens of actual attorneys for every one of yours. Don't double down on dumb decisions. You've taken a step in the right direction but you're still on probation, and we don't OWE you forgiveness.
29.1.2023 18:46There's more, but the bottom line is that until Hasbro acknowledges the FCP isn't worth the paper it's not printed upon, there...The FCP "asks". Keep asking, it's good to want things.
The FCP says to not use logos, trademarks, etc., or imply that it's official. That's already covered in trademark law and laws regarding implying endorsement. FCP is irrelevant.
The FCP says Wizards can use your "fan content" without permission. No, they can't, unless you have explicitly agreed to the FCP in which case you give it away. So don't.
The FCP is also now in direct conflict with section 4 item 3 with the CC stuff.
29.1.2023 18:41The FCP "asks". Keep asking, it's good to want things.The FCP says to not use logos, trademarks, etc., or imply that it's...Hasbro/Wizards of the Coast has released the core rulesystem of #5e #DnD under the Creative Commons By-Attribute 4.0 license. https://www.dndbeyond.com/posts/1439-ogl-1-0a-creative-commons
This is ONLY the System Reference Document (SRD), NOT the Player's Handbook or other supplements, and does not affect future versions of D&D.
This is a good thing. It's not perfect, because there is still a snake in the grass to be addressed (the Wizards Fan Content Policy https://company.wizards.com/en/legal/fancontentpolicy ) but my reading is that it's unenforceable.
29.1.2023 18:35Hasbro/Wizards of the Coast has released the core rulesystem of #5e #DnD under the Creative Commons By-Attribute 4.0 license....YouTube brags on its all-knowing "Algorithm" figures pit, based upon what you watch, what you skip, and what you block outright, what you want to see.
So. If the "Algorithm" is so smart, why does it continue to cram my recommendations full of Rogan crap and Tate misogyny when I block every last channel that shows me one of those two holding forth?
If the "Algorithm" is so bad at that, how can it accurately identify what's "advertiser friendly" and what's not? Or which accounts to auto-ban?
23.1.2023 06:12YouTube brags on its all-knowing "Algorithm" figures pit, based upon what you watch, what you skip, and what you block outright,...#silentsunday Waterfall fog south of San Francisco (iPhone XR)
23.1.2023 04:58#silentsunday Waterfall fog south of San Francisco (iPhone XR)VirusTotal analysis at https://www.virustotal.com/gui/file/4e83135b33795d21adf1fea2910be2f33b84e3f0f3bc8ebef6e92711220e3c45?nocache=1
23.1.2023 04:00VirusTotal analysis at https://www.virustotal.com/gui/file/4e83135b33795d21adf1fea2910be2f33b84e3f0f3bc8ebef6e92711220e3c45?nocache=1Free to you all, unencumbered by #OGL license issues, I offer "The Dragon's Rest Inn", an adventure compatible with #DnD #5e, suitable for 5th-7th level adventurers, including a 9-page PDF, 2 super-high-resolution maps suitable for VTTs, 3 new magic items, 6 new monsters, and hooks for additional adventures. You can come git you some at https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1ipV25DaNTM6B24bCL4qURlAoAvR7FxbE ... please let me know what you think!
Sukkit, HasBeen. releasing under Creative Commons CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 and you can't stop me!
23.1.2023 04:00Free to you all, unencumbered by #OGL license issues, I offer "The Dragon's Rest Inn", an adventure compatible with #DnD #5e,...Cancelled my DnDBeyond subscription.
Not one more penny to Hasbro.
20.1.2023 14:58Cancelled my DnDBeyond subscription.Not one more penny to Hasbro.Content warning:Open Game License anger
What is saddest is that, as I forever turn my back to Hasbro, it is not just #DnD that I reject. If I am to be true to my principles, there are other Hasbro properties I can never again support. Anything they own is now tainted.
Farewell, Optimus Prime. Goodbye, Princess Celestia. You have been betrayed and soiled by evil men and women who believe themselves beyond reproach.
19.1.2023 07:38Content warning:Open Game License angerWhat is saddest is that, as I forever turn my back to Hasbro, it is not just #DnD that I reject. If I...Content warning:Open Game License anger
This will go down in business history alongside Elon Musk's ruination of Twitter as extreme examples of incompetent handling of a previously well-received brand. This is what is meant by "killing the goose that laid the golden eggs"; it is the face of unrestrained greed.
19.1.2023 07:33Content warning:Open Game License angerThis will go down in business history alongside Elon Musk's ruination of Twitter as extreme...Content warning:Open Game License anger
Facts:
https://www.fool.com/investing/2023/01/17/big-change-coming-for-hasbro-should-investor-worry/
Wizards of the Coast, the division of Hasbro that makes Magic the Gathering and Dungeons&Dragons, accounts for 22% of revenue but 72% of profit for ALL OF HASBRO, meaning that WotC is carrying Hasbro on its back. It costs next to nothing to operate that free-money machine.
And by trying to force even more out of it, they've utterly destroyed all goodwill and trust.
Nice job, Hasbro. Have you been taking Musk lessons?
19.1.2023 07:30Content warning:Open Game License...@goaty My experience with the Xenyx USB interfaces have been"
... "the drivers work well unlike other FOCUSRITE drivers that YAMAHA were nothing but trouble"
.... "hardware compressor per channel? Neat!"
...."excellent preamps, gimme that low-gain pickup action without adding noise"
... and "oh crap the power supply on the 1222 died and it's built in and a real pain to fix, owell time for a new one".
For 250-ish bucks, that 12-channel beastie was a bargain.
14.1.2023 04:18@goaty My experience with the Xenyx USB interfaces have been"... "the drivers work well unlike other FOCUSRITE drivers that YAMAHA...Here are just a few publishers whom you should consider for your fantasy tabletop game materials:
Paizo / Pathfinder: https://paizo.com
Kobold Press https://koboldpress.com
MCDM https://www.mcdmproductions.com
Mage Hand Press https://magehandpress.com
Ghostfire Gaming https://ghostfiregaming.com
Here is whom you should NOT support:
Hasbro
Wizards of the Coast
Content warning:a bit more Open Gaming License 1.1 rant
Their contention that they can seize and monetize MY work WITHOUT COMPENSATION is utter bullshit (yes, OGL 1.1 asserted exactly that) and that they can take down MY reviews, creations or live-play (yes, OGL 1.1 asserted exactly that) is Musk-grade evil.
Though they're backtracking NOW, they've made their intent known, and will inevitably try to make the money- and control-grab incrementally.
Time to abandon D&D and go to other systems. As stated, I'm out.
13.1.2023 20:24Content warning:a bit more Open Gaming License 1.1 rantTheir contention that they can seize and monetize MY work WITHOUT COMPENSATION is...Content warning:more Open Gaming License 1.1 rant
What Hasbro is doing is a verbatim "I am altering the deal, pray I don’t alter it any further" money grab. Their CEO's contention that D&D is "undermonetized" is not just greedy; it's their own fault. The third-party ecosystem exists because Hasbro itself has left gaps in the system and released mediocre supplements. If WotC was performing, we'd be buying from them.
What they are doing is anticompetitive, and is likely illegal as such. It's also immoral AF.
13.1.2023 19:55Content warning:more Open Gaming License 1.1 rantWhat Hasbro is doing is a verbatim "I am altering the deal, pray I don’t alter it...Content warning:Open Gaming License 1.1 rant
I don't believe outrage-clickbait without evidence. I've withheld judgement on #OGL 1.1 until I saw it myself and REAL lawyers have analyzed it.
For 45 years I've been playing/dungeon mastering #DnD. Yes I'm old. In that context I have never felt as betrayed as I do now. Hasbro has burned trust to the ground; anything they say now is considered a lie.
My current D&D campaign is my last. I'll finish it under 5e. Anything new will NOT be anything Hasbro controls.
13.1.2023 19:46Content warning:Open Gaming License 1.1 rantI don't believe outrage-clickbait without evidence. I've withheld judgement on #OGL 1.1...Basically, if I want coverage equivalent to PHB + XGE + TGE + DMG, what's the Pathfinder book set that delivers the same diversity? I don't want to go down the path (heh) of having to buy a bunch of 40 dollar supplement books only to use 2-3 pages in a supplement book (i.e. the Games Workshop "Screw You" macrotransaction business model).
12.1.2023 19:39Basically, if I want coverage equivalent to PHB + XGE + TGE + DMG, what's the Pathfinder book set that delivers the same diversity? I...Folks who play #Pathfinder ... it seems that there are a LOT more sourcebooks to buy than That Other Fantasy Game if you want a broad range of character races, archetypes, subclasses, etc. Is this an accurate assessment? It seems that if I'm going to get a similar "coverage" it's going to be very pricey.
Whatever drama about #DnD and the rumors about the 1.1 #OGL, it seems a lot less expensive (or in my case, already paid for).
12.1.2023 19:15Folks who play #Pathfinder ... it seems that there are a LOT more sourcebooks to buy than That Other Fantasy Game if you want a broad range...Sooooooo.
I was messing with #ChatGPT and thought I'd check its #AI creative capabilities as well as its understanding of #dnd.
I am disturbed by the high quality of the results.
See for yourself, O Obsolete Human.
12.1.2023 07:32Sooooooo.I was messing with #ChatGPT and thought I'd check its #AI creative capabilities as well as its understanding of #dnd. I am...Spew hate on forums
Hide behind anonymity
Banhammer on balls
A quest for knowledge
Names of all of the Naaru
Is there one named Kosh?
Mageroyal is red
And Mountain Silversage? Blue
Tauren will eat both
Hordies raid your towns
Alliance collects taxes
What's the difference?
Mulgore's great treasure
The great pride of Thunder Bluff
It's Tauren booty
Wynn has no mommy
But Thrall has a grandmother
That's why he's nicer
Hunter! Control your pet!
He's pulling extra aggro
And humping my leg
/end
1.1.2023 22:05Spew hate on forumsHide behind anonymityBanhammer on ballsA quest for knowledgeNames of all of the NaaruIs there one named Kosh?Mageroyal is...